Cummins 4BT & Diesel Conversions Forums banner

Loose bolts and leaks

6.2K views 17 replies 8 participants last post by  char1355  
#1 ·
First time poster, long time lurker here - my excuse for the wordiness of this post!

To start with, thanks to this site and other forum members for all the great information. A little background on my truck - I purchased an '89 F150, 4x4 last spring from a retired diesel mechanic who had swapped in a 4bt out of a bread truck. The engine had very recently been remanned by Reviva when he bought the truck (Hostess fall-out), and currently has around 35,000 miles on it since the rebuild. For those wondering it's stock, 105 HP, 2600 rpm, VE pump.

A few months after I bought the truck, I parked it my shop for a month to do some body work, strip off the old chalky Missouri paint and repaint the truck. I noticed that it was leaking some oil, but didn't think much of it as cummins have a reputation for leaks. I put about 3,000 miles on the truck over summer and fall, maybe adding a quart-2 quarts oil. Fast forward to last week - I took the truck on a 2,000 mile road trip from northern mi to visit family in northern new england, mostly because I love driving it and my wife is a good sport. She performed flawlessly, but the nagging leak seemed to get considerably worse on the return leg, which involved some heavy climbs over mountains in VT and was following a fresh oil change at my father's house. After getting home, cleaning up the engine and going for a few drives, seemed like the leak was coming from the bottom of the timing cover, drivers side. I checked a few of the bolts and they were pretty loose. Snugged everything up good, went for another drive, and it looks bone dry under the cover. Prior to the tightening you could start to see a small flow of oil after a few minutes of driving.

So my questions:

1. Seems like these engines have a reputation for shaking bolts loose, but does this seem normal after only 35,000 miles?

2. Is the timing cover a particular problem area for this, or should I check other bolts on the engine to make sure the same thing isn't occurring?

3. I don't own a torque wrench - could I do any harm tightening these bolts up by feel?

4. Unrelated - in researching this engine over the past year I've come across mention of the KDP quite a few times. I would assume that Reviva would deal with the KDP issue during remanufacture. Anyone familiar with Reviva know if this is the case or not?

Thanks for your input on this, and thanks again for being such a great resource.
 
#2 · (Edited)
Welcome to the forum. Yes, the little 4bt is a vibrating monster and can loosen bolts occasionally. Especially if they weren't torqued correctly to begin with. Where the cover attaches to the front gear housing is a known leak area. Although there is a gasket for that spot, seems like Cummins recommends a gasket compound instead. I believe all those bolts torque to 18 ft lbs which isn't an extreme amount. A torque wrench isn't an extremely expensive tool and might be a good investment. Thread sealer is recommended on some of the engine bolts, but don't believe it's on those. As to whether the KDP issue was repaired I can't say. About the only way to know for sure is remove the front cover and look. Doing that would require replacing the front crank seal since that can't be reused. Also, there are several bolts behind that cover that are notorious for working loose. Those are supposed to have blue Loctite used on them. The bolts holding the lower crank pulley also use Loctite. Think those recommend the red version which is even stronger. Sometimes have to heat those bolt a little to break them loose. If you knew someone with one of the camera probes you could insert it in the port on the front of the cover and look at the area of the KDP to keep from removing it.
 
#3 ·
On my 4BT when i tppk it out of the bread truck with just over 200,000 miles i noticed some lose bolts and when I did the KDP fix all of the timing housing bolts were lose.
Having worked as a machinist/mechanic in the maintenance field I used the rule we used there "blue locktite on everything if it shakes,rattles or rolls" so every bolt that needed to be re tightened got the internal and external threads cleaned with Brake-kleen then dried and blue locktite applied unless red was required.
When I did my overhaul last year I locktited everything except the valve cover bolts and exhaust manifold bolts as they get so hot that there was no point, I look at it as cheap insurance over the long haul............$.02
 
#4 ·
Thanks for the replies. Look like I spoke too soon- 80 mile round trip today and the leak started back up. Definetly the timing cover, just to drivers side of main pulley where there's a slight lip in the cover bottom and a bolt with a larger head than the others. Going to pick up a torque wrench this week and check the cover bolts (and anything else I can reach for proper torque). It does seem strange that it got worse so quickly.

If that doesn't solve it, I might take a stab at pulling the cover and resealing (plus checking kdp and housing bolts). Feels a little daunting to an amatuer like me, but that's how you learn, right?

Thanks again
 
#5 ·
Also, like Steve said, get yourself a few cans of the brake cleaner to remove the junk in the holes. Spend a few bucks an get you a few bottoming taps of the correct size to run in the holes to make sure the threads are clean.I believe there is a listing of torque specs for the bolts posted on the forum. The vast majority of the external bolts are 18 ft lbs. The crank pulley bolts are different. Should you decide to remove the front cover, replacing the front crank seal will be necessary. When you reinstall the cover, the crank must be totally dry and free of oil. Otherwise the seal will leak. And as I said, RTV has become the accepted seal material for that front cover.
 
#6 ·
Update-

I picked up a proper torque wrench and cranked the cover bolts down to spec. Still leaking badly after the block has gotten good and warm. Seemed like maybe leak was coming more from vacuum pump area. In looking around I noticed a chip out of the timing housing itself, on the backside just where it clears the block under the vacuum pump. When I got home from a drive today I climbed under and cranked my head around to see what looked like fresh oil coming from the chip. I'm thinking it's possible there could be a crack there that's opening up when the housing iron gets hot enough. Maybe damage from the swap, or something else...

Any ideas of possible causes, and a fix? Weld, replace housing, etc? I attached a photo, chip is visible dead center of pic on backside of housing.

Thanks again
 
#7 ·
Can't really tell, but is that a crack or just a seam in the front housing? If it is cracked, it could be welded. Means taking it off along with everything attached to it. Could also be the gasket between the PS pump and front cover leaking or the gasket between the front cover and the block. Lots of possibles there.
 
#8 ·
I had to fix a cracked timing housing about a month ago. It was ultimately caused by not having a support bracket from my vacuum/power steering pump to the block to prevent shaking the timing case up too badly. The bracket also supports the end of the injection pump. Mine was cracked right through and I was loosing about a quart of oil a week and I wasn't having much luck with RTV or other sealers to stop it. I ordered a new 5.9 timing cover off ebay to fix the issue, but its a pain because the cam had to come out to get the timing case off.
 
#11 ·
The support brace is nothing fancy. It's just a simple angle brace. Here's a video by Gould Gear and Electric who is the premier rebuilder of those pump. You can see the brace in their video. Main problem is on the 4bt the injection pump brace is using the same territory so something custom has to be devised. I think some may have welded a piece to the pump brace to act as the support. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJhR48a-9R8
 
#13 ·
i had a similar issue last summer. i purchased a swapped truck as well, and it looks like the cause of the issue was the welded on bracket to support the ps/vac pump. it looked like the hole drilled in the bracket was slightly off causing pressure on the pump housing. mine failed in a spectacular fashion, and with the replacement we opened up the hole in the bracket with a drill. haven't had a chance to put much more mileage on it but it's been trouble free so far. i attached the photo of my bracket

 
#18 ·
Those engine mounts are probably the best for a 4bt. However, the engine mount controls vibration being transmitted to the vehicle, not vibration within the engine. Controlling loose bolts is normally by the use of a thread sealant like Loctite. Usually not needed in all locations be some of the more critical ones. KDP is an issue that must be controlled either by installing a small tab covering that hose or using a punch to expand the metal around that hole. Later housings had holes that were smaller at the front thus preventing the pin to slip out. Most standard B series and early 24 valves had the pin issue.